Youth Athletes
- 2005 – Margaret Liederbach, Chip Koziara
- 2006 – Jimmy Hibbler, Zach Phillips, Megan Tompkins
- 2007 – Sam Dart, Tara Simon
- 2008 – Anna Godzik
- 2009 – Shannon Marie Cosens
- 2010 – Hunter Viles
- 2011 – Lilly Chamberlin, Kurt Boucher
- 2012 – Sophia Thompson, Mitchell Hoffman
- 2014 – Allison Hoffman, Petoskey St. Francis Middle School
- 2015 – Sophie Snyder,Nathaniel Wandrie
- 2016 – Mason McFadden
- 2017 – N/A
- 2018 – N/A
- 2019 – N/A
High School Athletes
- 2005 – Nik Burkhart, Casey Wilcox
- 2006 – Josh Klevorn, Steve Whittaker
- 2007 – Jessica Hass
- 2008 – Justin Litzner
- 2009 – Stephen Kolb, Bernadette LeBlanc
- 2010 – Alex Kenney, Caitlin Ludlow
- 2011 – Taylor Smith, Jackson Kopka
- 2012 – Hannah Loesch, Luke Hawley
- 2013 – Briana Burris, Inland Lakes; Andrew Furstenburg, Harbor Springs
- 2014 – Abbie Welch, Pellston; Duane Vizina, Inland Lakes
- 2015 – Sadie Cwikiel, Adam McCain
- 2016 – Jill Atwood, Ryan Bailey, Marcus Matelski
- 2017 – Jordan Young, Colin Shepard
- 2018 – Katie King, Jake Lee
- 2019 – Kaitlin Schwenke, Peter Willcome
Parents
- 2005 – Sharon Hofbauer, Brian Shurtleff
- 2006 – Diana Johnson, Hoagie & Brook Kleinhenz
- 2007 – Kim Wagenschutz
- 2008 – Jim & Candi Wynn
- 2009 -Don & Sharalen Greenwell
- 2010 – Barret & Katie Ludlow
- 2011 – Tom & Connie Fairbairn
- 2012 – Dennis Mikus
- 2013 – Mike & Chris Way (Charlevoix)
- 2014 – Jon & Meribeth Thompson (Alanson)
- 2015 – Anne Petrie
- 2016 – Carole & Frank Lamberti
- 2017 – Karen Flynn
- 2018 – Sandy & Joe Lee
- 2019 – N/A
Fantastic Fans
- 2005 – Jim & Carol Helmer, Dick & Barb Kutcipal, Stephen & Irene Whittaker
- 2006 – Howard & Becky Morse, Frank & Irene Zulski
- 2007 – Jim & Carolyn Cloutier
- 2008 – Bob & Joann Palmer
- 2009 – Don & Sharalen Greenwell
- 2010 – Mike Suter & Taylor Golding (Blue Crew)
- 2012 – Gary & Mary Ann Roberts
- 2013 – Tim & Kathy Drenth, East Jordan
- 2014 – Tony Cutler – East Jordan
- 2015 – Dave Wallis – Mackinaw City
- 2016 – Ed Vondra
- 2017 – Cheryl & Jim Brown
- 2018 – Eligh Wynkoop
- 2019 – N/A
Youth Coaches
- 2005 – Zach Jonker, Frank Lamberti
- 2006 – Matt Berger, Monica Speigl
- 2007 – Gary Hunter
- 2009 – Paula Beyer
- 2011 – Dree Lo
- 2013 – Brian Drayton, Petoskey St. Francis Middle School Basketball
- 2014 – Paul Vining, Petoskey Youth Wrestling
- 2015 – Ashlee Lechowicz, Kyle Lieberman
- 2016 – Carl Vanderwall
- 2017 – N/A
- 2018 – N/A
- 2019 – George Newson
High School Coaches
- 2005 – Mark Fralick, Mike & Emily Kloss
- 2006 – Don Dickman, Heidi Hewitt, Monica Kline, Jeff Kruzel, Mary Miller, Scott Mills, Beth Ristow, Mike Wilson
- 2007 – Terry Lee Smith, Ralph Tramontini
- 2008 – Clark Hewitt, Scott Batchelor
- 2009 – Chris Myers
- 2010 – Dave Hills
- 2011 – Randy Bricker
- 2012 – Kerry VanOrman, Petoskey High School Football
- 2013 – Dennis Starkey, Petoskey High School Basketball; Mark Stormzand, Cheboygan Girl’s Soccer
- 2014 – Bill Chase, East Jordan Basketball, Tennis, Track
- 2015 – Pete Kelbel, Harbor Springs, Golf
- 2016 – Meg Kitson, East Jordan
- 2017 – John Martin
- 2018 – Sean Ferguson, Jason Roussin
- 2019 – Matt Peterson
Youth Sport Leaders
- 2005 – Dennis McGeath, Margaret Ruemenapp
- 2006 – Bill Hansen, Sr.
- 2007 – Steve Braun, Tom Litzner
- 2008 – Keith Demeuse, Kelly Kolb
- 2009 – Tracy Maurer
- 2011 – Mary Weitzel-Bailey
- 2012 – Al Gooch
- 2013 – Patricia Lamberti, PYSA
- 2014 – Matt Walton, East Jordan Pop Warner Football
- 2015 – Mike Larson
- 2016 – N/A
- 2017 – Miigwaans Smith
- 2018 – N/A
- 2019 – Richard Phillips
Teams of Character
- 2005 – Harbor Light Christian Volleyball
- 2009 – Harbor Springs Girl’s Cross Country, Petoskey Boy’s Soccer
- 2010 – Pellston Volleyball
- 2011 – Petoskey Boy’s Basketball
- 2012 Charlevoix Girl’s Cross Country
- 2014 – Petoskey Youth Soccer Association Boy’s U-15 Laker’s
- 2015 – East Jordan High School Varsity Football Team
- 2016 – Pellston Volleyball
- 2017 – Petoskey High School Boys Golf
- 2018 – East Jordan High School Competitive Cheer Team
- 2019 – Petoskey Middle School 7th Grade Volleyball Team
Lifetime Achievement
- 2005 – John Juday, Sr., Tom Turcott, David Schmalzried
- 2006 – Dick Harbaugh
- 2007 – Pete Wooters
- 2008 – Jerry Rosevear
- 2009 – Bill Hewitt
- 2011 – Dave Bricker
- 2012 – Margaret Ruemenapp
- 2013 – Jack Taylor, BTS Founder and Career College Coach, Football & Track
- 2014 – Ron Goodman; BTS Executive Director, High School official and Football Coach
- 2015 – Gary Hice, Petoskey High School
- 2016 – N/A
- 2017 – N/A
- 2018 – Dennis Starkey, Petoskey High School Boys Basketball Coach and Teacher
- 2019 – Karen Starkey, Petoskey High School Girls Track and Counselor
Officials
- 2005 – Burt Matteson, Tom Micham
- 2006 – Dick Olson
- 2008 – Mark Lenneman, Peter Fitzsimons, Jim Lamoreaoux
- 2011 – Dave Reeb
- 2012 – Harold Koviak
- 2013 – Ray Fisher, East Jordan (Track, Cross-Country); Gene Massey, St. Ignace (High School & College, 50 years football; 35 years basketball).
- 2014 – Justin Matzka, Petoskey (Soccer)
- 2015 – Paul Van Wagoner
- 2016 – Gary Francis
- 2017 – Joe Malec
- 2018 – N/A
- 2019 – Jim Kozlowski